Multimedia package: Liberians in Minnesota
Just out from the Star Tribune, which produces some of the best online journalism stories anywhere, this large package about immigrants from Liberia points the way toward improving journalism interface design.
Now, the story is excellent, and there’s great reporting here, and stunning photography too. The audio sequence in the intro Soundslides just blew me away, and the videos of the people living in Minnesota successfully show us what life is like for these immigrants. But in this post, I’m going to focus on the interface.
Why? Because so often, the interface for a big online story package makes a mess of everything.
This package is a rare exception. I know the credit goes to a whole team of folks working at the Star Tribune — many of them have been doing this for six or seven years or more. The experience shows in this package. Here are three things I particularly liked:
- Full window treatment: No pop-up at the start, and no added pop-ups later. The exceptions are a Star Tribune editor’s blog post about the story (opens in a new full window; comments are invited here, which is a very clever idea) and an external link to a PBS site (the package incorporates video from a 2002 documentary that originally aired on PBS — in itself a very interesting aspect of this package).
- The pull-down menu in the upper left corner works very gracefully, hiding itself automatically after you select something. It also opens sub-sections well. While at one point I thought I would not be able to tell which section I was currently in, as soon as I opened the menu to go somewhere else, I realized that the menu itself showed me clearly which section I was in. This made it easy to choose a new section without confusion.
- Perhaps my favorite thing — in the interface — is the integration of the text stories. This is absolutely brilliant. Just look at this solution to the all-too-common problem of “my multimedia and my long-form text are totally divorced from each other.” It’s an HTML page. Yet it is fully integrated with the multimedia package. Without being clumsily embedded inside it. I bet Dave Braunger came up with this — it’s such a brilliant solution, and Dave has the ActionScript know-how to pull this off. There are no extra windows. You go from the multimedia package to the HTML page and back again in one window, seamlessly. I want to fly out to Minneapolis and kiss the people who built this!
The design of this package — both visual and functional — is a milestone in multimedia journalism. It is the most successfully integrated online journalism package I have ever seen. I know that sounds all technical and cold, but it’s really a cause for emotional celebration. Here is a model for everyone — if you’re going to invest this much time and effort in reporting such a story (and I love it that it’s local, local, local), then THIS is the way to put it online.
And for heaven’s sake, DON’T change the URL!
(If you hit the registration wall at the Star Tribune site, get a free login from Bugmenot.)
Update (11:23 a.m.): Oh. My. Gosh. It sets a cookie for you. It remembers where you left off. Go to a segment. Close your browser. Open the browser again and return to the package. You will be in the last segment you were viewing! (Dave!!!)
Technorati tags: Flash | Flash journalism | infographics | information graphics | design | journalism | storytelling | examples


::grin:: The smart thing to do would be to base my critique of that package off this post.
February 20, 2007 at 7:13 pmNo, no, no! That would not be fair, O student.
February 20, 2007 at 9:10 pmLove it, love it, love it!
Finally. We’re doing it, huh?
I too was most impressed with the interface. It is the icing on top of a deep package with solid reporting and storytelling behind it. Bravo to all who worked on the project.
I hope we continue to explore this form of presentation.
February 21, 2007 at 3:56 amI thought the intro slideshow was brilliant … A definite hook to pull one into the package. I didn’t have time when I first saw it to explore the rest, but this post encourages me to go back now.
February 23, 2007 at 5:04 amMany thanks for your analysis of this project, Mindy. Combination of both you and Al calling attention to it proved irresistible, even amid seminar prep! The opener is one of the most effective Soundslides I’ve ever seen. Correction. THE most effective…
February 25, 2007 at 8:19 pm[...] Minneapolis, Minnesota) is one of the all-time best online multimedia packages — ever. I wrote about it at length in February 2007. There are lots of reasons to admire and marvel at this package; perhaps the best [...]
September 15, 2007 at 11:08 amThe big question I always have: how do you present those great documentaries inside your site? There’s no navigation from and to other packages. It is a stand alone solution and I think that that is not right. It should be integral part of the website. Why? Branding, usability and most important: continuity: how to incorporate follow-ups or related stories?
December 11, 2007 at 6:34 pm[...] People Torn, Star Tribune, Minneapolis (see my blog post about this [...]
February 26, 2008 at 12:52 am