Panel: ‘The Changing Media Landscape’

Mark your calendar …

What: A panel discussion about current trends, led by six “media influencers.” A different kind of panel (we hope), with a real conversation among the participants, and no PowerPoint in sight (Columbia Journalism Dialogues series).

When: Tuesday, Nov. 13, 2007, from 6:30 to 9 p.m.

Where: Columbia Graduate School of Journalism, Lecture Hall, third floor; 116th Street and Broadway, New York (see map)


  • Josh Cohen, business product manager, Google News
  • Hossein “Hoder” Derakhshan, an Iranian-born blogger, journalist, and Internet activist
  • Jonathan Dube, director of digital programming, CBC News
  • Andrew Lih, author of a new book on Wikipedia and expert on Chinese media
  • Mindy McAdams, new media education pioneer and professor at University of Florida
  • Michael Rogers, resident futurist at The New York Times
  • Sree Sreenivasan (panel moderator), dean of students, Columbia Journalism School, and technology reporter, WNBC-TV

No RSVP required. No charge. Open to the public. Reception from 6:30 to 7 p.m.

Update (Nov. 15): Archived video of the panel here.

Teaching video to reporters

Note to myself: Must teach students how to handle these two things (both lifted from a post by Cyndy Green).

(1) You know what you want in the story, so tell the reporter ahead of time HOW to shoot the exact footage and HOW to get the audio that you want. (This is much better than just hoping the reporter will figure out what to do with the camera.)

To keep it simple, we told the reporter before he went out to (a) interview the teacher about what they were doing and why, and (b) shoot about 90 seconds of the students working on the project. Teachers are great at talking non-stop with few “ahs” and “ums,” but first-graders are a little harder to work with. We decided ahead that we didn’t have time to mess with that. Back at The Rep, we edited the video to dub the teacher’s interview over the footage of the students. Worked great even though the reporter had no training on the camera because we gave specific instructions ahead on what he should shoot. It took roughly 35 minutes using Windows Movie Maker to edit.

(2) Does the reporter know how to use the camera fast in a breaking-news situation? Does he know what to do with the video upon returning to the newsroom?

A crash around noon during which a toddler was thrown from a car window was unexpected breaking news Tuesday. The chief photographer grabbed a point and shoot and captured the scene. He filmed while the reporter was interviewing a safety official. This video we wanted to get on right away because it was soon dated. The official didn’t know answers to some of the questions. The photographer had put a video together then showed it to a line editor for approval. We wasted some time there because changes needed to be made in the video. We should have had the editor looking at the raw footage when it came in and giving editing instructions, just as we coach our print stories before they’re written. [Note to self, for breaking news: Editors must see raw, unedited video immediately.] Essentially, we had to do the editing again, which took about 20 minutes the second time using iMovie.

Both examples were provided by Veronica VanDress, assistant city editor at the Canton Repository, a newspaper in Canton, Ohio.
These are realistic situations that can be taught. That is, an educator can train journalism students how to think this way.

On a day when I had spent three hours studying camera specifications and reviews, it was a great, great pleasure to think about the journalism part of reporter-shot video. Thanks, Cyndy.

Video in newsrooms today: Workflow

Usually I don’t post on a weekend, but you’ve got to read this if you work in journalism today, or if you hope to work in journalism in the future:

Video workload survey results

Andy Dickinson’s survey may not be scientific enough to be published in an academic journal, but it sure does give us food for thought:

  • Video is commonly shot and edited by the same person.
  • Reporters are expected to shoot video and file copy on the same story.
  • Photographers are expected to shoot stills and video on the same story.
  • You should allow 4 hours to produce 1 minute of video. [I wish I were that good.]
  • There are no clearly defined roles in newsrooms for video.

Hey, he is talking about newspaper newsrooms, people! And that’s just the very top of a long and very informative post, by Andy, so please go and read it.

‘We who rule content must start making decisions’

The news is not all bad:

The research we did in cities in the U.S. and abroad this past summer provided compelling evidence that the news is as valuable as ever — even in an age where screen-based headlines overwhelm the senses and the next update is never more than a mouse-click away.

Young people the world over are hungry for news. They just don’t prefer our traditional platforms and packaging.

Source: Tom Curley, president and CEO of the Associated Press, speaking at a dinner in New York, Nov. 1, 2007.

It’s a realistic and inspiring speech. Well done, Mr. Curley.

Highlights picked out by Squared. My own highlights rendered here.

Tape vs. hard drive vs. card, and AVCHD

Planning to buy some video cameras for online journalism students to use, I’m doing buyer’s research.

I had been feeling confident about the Canon HV20 — under $1,000, with both microphone and headphone inputs. But some new information has interceded. If any of you have some advice to offer, please do.

First, a lot of people (and Web sites) have been talking about the move away from tape (goin’ tapeless!). I learned to shoot on Mini DV tapes, and I’m used to capturing from tape, but I do appreciate the convenience of copying a file (from a hard drive or memory card). It’s faster.

Second, I had a chat with Chet Rhodes, assistant managing editor for news video at, and he showed me a new camera he’s testing, the Sony CX7. It records to the Sony Memory Stick PRO Duo format memory card. Chet likes the idea that a reporter can drop the card into an envelope and overnight-mail it back to Washington. Can’t do that with a hard drive. He also likes the cool Bluetooth microphone from Sony. Unlike the typical “wireless” lavalier mic, this one really has NO wires.

Third, I started reading reviews of the Canon HG10, which records to a built-in hard drive. The price is a bit higher than the HV20, but if the hard drive is going to make life easier for the students, it would be worth it.

However, there’s a fourth point: A new video format, AVCHD.

From a review of the HG10:

Editing AVCHD footage is not impossible anymore, but it’s certainly no joy. Two programs have emerged that offer a decent array of editing tools for unconverted AVCHD files (.m2t extension for PCs): Ulead Video Studio 11 Plus and Sony Vegas Movie Studio 8. There are lots of other tools out there that allow you to convert AVCHD files to MPEG2 or whatever you need, and probably a few programs we don’t even know about, but these are the big two. Unfortunately, Vegas is only available with Sony AVCHD camcorders, not Panasonic or Canon. So we’re left with Ulead.

There are further constraints. Software engineers were tearing their hair out for awhile trying to create efficient ways to deal with the tightly woven algorithms. Working with AVCHD is taxing on your computer, and you’re going to need a powerhouse processor and memory to do it with any expediency.

Well, as you might imagine, it’s not as if I can guarantee that each student will have access to “a powerhouse processor” and giant stacks of memory.

Now, back to Chet, who was kind enough to answer a couple of questions about AVCHD (which the Sony CX7 also uses). Currently his people are using the CX7 in SD mode — so they are recording in an MPEG format, not AVCHD. “Once more editing software supports AVCHD, then we might move that way,” he wrote in an e-mail.

From what I can tell at the Canon site, the HG10 records in ACVHD (MPEG-4 AVCH/H.264: 5/7/9/15 Mbps) only. So unless I’m mistaken, we don’t have the ability to edit the footage in our computer labs, because of the limitations of our hardware and software.

A PC World article from 2006 explains the AVCHD format and its limitations pretty well.

In the meantime, iMovie ’08 reportedly does support the HG10’s flavor of AVCHD. Final Cut Pro 6.0.1 offers support for AVCHD, with some limitations (such as no Firewire). I can’t find any evidence that Windows Movie Maker supports AVCHD at this time.

So I was getting all excited about tapeless video, but now it seems that with the limitations of university computer labs to contend with, I might be buying those Canon HV20 cameras after all.

Update (Feb. 23, 2008): We did buy four of the HV20 cameras, and so far, they are working out very well. One of the benefits to using tape with students is that I can make them hand in the tapes so I can grade (or at least critique) their raw footage. You’ll want to figure out how many tapes each student will need in the semester and charge a lab fee to cover the costs; buying tape in boxes of 50 or 100 is much cheaper than buying a three-pack at Best Buy.

How video should be used on the Web by newspapers

Cyndy Green on the benefits of using a small video camera:

I am no longer an invader, infecting the story with my mere presence. I am invisible. An old(er) lady with a camera. Ignored. I can now see the real story … not necessarily the story being acted out for the benefit of the camera.

More in a short, sweet post about exploring video storytelling for journalism.

Green worked in TV news for 28 years, carrying a very, very big camera. Now, as a high school teacher, she’s experimenting with smaller, cheaper cameras.

First lesson in audio for journalists

I am getting a little weary of hearing journalists and educators say they don’t know how to do audio.

Let’s see whether I can translate my less-than-50-minute* lesson into plain text.

Gathering Audio

It helps if you are holding the recorder, mic and cable — and demonstrating while you teach this. (Sorry, I don’t have video of me teaching it!)

  1. Always use an external microphone.
  2. Make sure the recorder is recording before you start.
  3. Let the subject do the talking.
  4. Don’t say “Uh huh” or “Mm hm.” Learn to nod silently and make great eye contact so they know you are listening closely.
  5. Ask questions that lead the subject to tell a story.
  6. Collect relevant natural sound, e.g., hammers, crowds, water, traffic, street musicians.
  7. Never let the subject hold the mic, and don’t move your hand on the mic.
  8. Don’t swing or bump the mic cable.
  9. Carry spare batteries.
  10. Ask the subject to say his or her full name, job title, home town, etc. — at the end. If they say it too fast, ask them to say it again, more slowly.

Practice Gathering Audio

If you have gear, or if the students have gear:

  1. Put students in teams of two, with one recorder and one mic for each pair.
  2. Send them outdoors, and tell them to interview each other (one at a time, please) for five minutes.
  3. Tell them to be careful about background noise in the spot they choose.
  4. Require them to WEAR HEADPHONES while they conduct the interview. What they hear in the headphones is what the recorder is recording. (If the interview subject’s P’s and S’s are too pronounced, the mic is too close to the subject’s mouth. Move it.)

Editing Audio

Editing audio in Audacity, a free program

  1. Open Audacity (more about that below).
  2. Open this file (or one like it) in Audacity. This file is a good one to use because: (a) it is very short; and (b) it has clear pauses between statements, which make it easy to demonstrate selecting bites.
  3. Show the students how to delete the preliminary stuff at the beginning: Select and delete (press the Delete key).
  4. Show the students how to undo (Edit menu, or Ctrl-Z, or Cmd-Z).
  5. Show the students how to MOVE a piece of audio from the end of the clip to another place in the clip: Select, cut, click on the new place, and paste (use the Edit menu, or use Ctrl-X and Ctrl-V; on a Mac, it’s Cmd-X and Cmd-V).

You’re done. Those are the basics of editing digital audio.

I always tell students: It’s like using Microsoft Word, which every reporter already knows how to do. Cut, copy, paste. You already know how to do this.

Practice Editing Audio

If you have computers, or if the students have computers, with Audacity installed:

  1. Copy the file onto the hard drive.
  2. Convert from WMA to WAV (if necessary).
  3. Open the file in Audacity.
  4. Edit the interview you just completed to a length of 45 to 60 seconds.
  5. Cut out all the “ums” and “ahs.”
  6. Move the subject’s introduction from the end to the beginning.
  7. Save and export as an MP3 file.

If you are a journalism educator, I can promise you — these take less time to grade than a 300-word (written) news story. You can complete this entire training — including gathering AND editing — in less than three hours. I have done it lots of times! The students can turn in their first edited audio project at the end of the class.

* If it’s all hands-on, you’ll need about 2.5 to 3 hours. If it’s only show-and-tell, with no hands-on, you can do it in less than one hour.

Grading Criteria for First Audio Exercise

  • 2 points: The audio is interesting and tells a coherent story.
  • 2 points: The audio sounds clear, and the quality is good.
  • 1 point: The length is between 45 and 60 seconds.

(I am assuming your students already know how to conduct a journalistic interview.)

Use this handout (PDF, 236 KB) for instructions. It explains not only how to do all of the editing, but also, how to download and install Audacity — which is free and works on Windows, Mac and Linux.

In most cases, I’m using a sub-$100 Olympus digital recorder. I have mics that cost abut $100 each and others that cost about $15 each. The cable costs about $10. So you can put together a usable audio kit for about $100 altogether.

When you are ready for more, look here.